HealthBlawg

David Harlow's Health Care Law Blog

    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • RSS
    • Email
  • About
  • Archives
  • Podcast
  • Press
  • Awards/Reviews
  • HIPAA
  • HCSM

Massachusetts universal health insurance law: Changes in regs could prompt ERISA pre-emption challenge

September 8, 2008

Massachusetts has famously gotten many of the state's uninsured covered thanks to the state mandate.  The "pay or play" approach taken has long seemed ripe for an ERISA pre-emption challenge (cf. the Wal-Mart case in Maryland).  The program now seems to be a victim of its own success, with enrollment in subsidized plans exceeding expectations, and the Commonwealth looking for additional revenues to fund the $130M shortfall.  One approach now proposed is to apply the "pay" part of the pay or play rule to a broader swath of employers — including many that have been "playing" by the rules to date.

As the Boston Globe reported last week, 

The current law requires most employers with more than 10 full-time employees to offer health coverage or to pay an annual "fair share" penalty of $295 per worker. It gives companies an option of paying at least 33 percent of full-time workers' premiums within the first 90 days of employment or making sure that at least 25 percent of their full-time workers are covered by an employer plan.

But the proposed new regulations would require employers to meet both requirements, or pay the penalty. The rules, if adopted, would take effect Oct. 1 and raise about $45 million this fiscal year, according to state documents.

The Globe article notes that Matt Fishman, VP for community health at our local 800-pound gorilla, Partners Healthcare (the biggest health care system, and also the biggest employer, in the Commonwealth) argued against that change not because Partners would rather not comply, but because the change, he fears, would open the doors to a legal challenge. 

The commentariat and blogerati have been divided to date on whether the Massachusetts version of pay or play would survive an ERISA preemption challenge. (Examples here, here, here and here.)  Personally, I have taken the cynical-realist approach, expecting that so long as the penalty for not playing remained as artificially low as the $295 a head figure in the initial Massachusetts rules, and the definition of "playing" was as expansive as it has been, it would not be worthwhile to mount a challenge.  I agree with Matt that ratcheting up the stakes in the pay or play game make it more likely that someone will pull the trigger and initiate an ERISA pre-emption challenge. 

I won't hold my breath waiting for an amendment of ERISA that would eliminate the possibility of such a lawsuit — Some have been waiting for such an amendment for years; some have been inveighing against it as leading to an unworkable morass of state-by-state mandates that would be difficult for large employers to comply with, which is what the ERISA provision was intended to avoid in the first place.  Of course, if this country is really ready for health care reform in a big way (a very big if), this will become a moot question.

— David Harlow   

Filed Under: Health care policy, Health Law, Massachusetts, Universal Health Care

you might also like:

  1. ERISA pre-emption ruling bites San Fran health care coverage mandate

  2. Universal Health Care, Wal-Mart, Maryland and Massachusetts

  3. All Payor Claims Databases: ERISA Pre-emption and the Tragedy of the Commons

« When it comes to antibiotics, less is more: no-pay rules for hospital-acquired infections motivate change in prescribing behavior
A flibbertigibbet, a will-o'-the-wisp, a blog! »

Follow me on Twitter

David Harlow 💉😷 Follow 42,915 17,570

Mastodon @healthblawg@c.im #HealthCare #MedDevice #Compliance #Privacy @MyOmnipod #HIPAA #digitalhealth #HarlowOnHC #pinksocks Tweets are tweets No more no less

healthblawg
healthblawg avatar; David Harlow 💉😷 @healthblawg ·
2h 1620898131004072027

The Harlow #Healthcare #Innovation Daily #digitalhealth #hcldr #HarlowOnHC Thanks to @Mr_Don_Auto @KardonHIPAA @vadernauts #digitalhealth #healthtech

Image for twitter card

'She handed the police my entire prescription list': Customer claims CVS called the police on him, violated HIPAA

dailydot.com A TikToker revealed a CVS Pharmacy pharmacist called him “insane” and reported him to police ...

paper.li

Reply on Twitter 1620898131004072027 Retweet on Twitter 1620898131004072027 0 Like on Twitter 1620898131004072027 0 Twitter 1620898131004072027
healthblawg avatar; David Harlow 💉😷 @healthblawg ·
5h 1620842034113175552

ICYMI> Interoperability and NLP with Kyle Silvestro, CEO of SyTrue — Harlow On Healthcare https://healthblawg.com/2022/03/interoperability-nlp-sytrue.html?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=ReviveOldPost #digitalhealth #hcldr #hitsm

Image for the Tweet beginning: ICYMI>  Interoperability and NLP Twitter feed image.
Reply on Twitter 1620842034113175552 Retweet on Twitter 1620842034113175552 0 Like on Twitter 1620842034113175552 0 Twitter 1620842034113175552
healthblawg avatar; David Harlow 💉😷 @healthblawg ·
8h 1620801819612946434

The latest Harlow On Health Care Daily #HarlowOnHC #digitalhealth #healthcare #innovation #privacy #hcldr Thx: @TWDigitalHealth @MrsYisWhy @thecommunityvc #digitalhealth #healthtech

Image for twitter card

Artificial intelligence model finds potential drug molecules a thousand times faster

techxplore.com The entirety of the known universe is teeming with an infinite number of molecules. But what fraction...

paper.li

Reply on Twitter 1620801819612946434 Retweet on Twitter 1620801819612946434 0 Like on Twitter 1620801819612946434 0 Twitter 1620801819612946434
Load More
Follow me on Mastodon

HIPAAtools

Hipaatools

The HIPAA Compliance Toolkit

The Walking Gallery

The Walking Gallery

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Categories
  • Archives
  • Podcast Interviews
  • HIPAAtools
  • HIPAA Compliance
  • Health Care Social Media
  • Speaking
  • In the Press
  • Blogroll

David Harlow

David Harlow

HealthcareNOW Radio

Connect with David

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Email
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Book Me: Speaking
  • About
  • The Harlow Group LLC
Copyright © 2006–2023
HealthBlawg is a publication of The Harlow Group LLC. See Copyright notice and disclaimer.
Fair use with attribution and a link is encouraged. Click for more on David Harlow.
[footer_backtotop text="Back to top" href="#"]