HealthBlawg

David Harlow's Health Care Law Blog

    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • RSS
    • Email
  • About
  • Archives
  • Podcast
  • Press
  • Awards/Reviews
  • HIPAA
  • HCSM

Universal Health Care, Wal-Mart, Maryland and Massachusetts

July 21, 2006

Since the passage of the Massachusetts Universal Health Care Law, many folks have been wondering "what about ERISA pre-emption?"  (OK, maybe not that many.)  In a nutshell (and with apologies to ERISA lawyers), Federal ERISA law pre-empts state law that relates to insurance in the context of employee benefits.  Richard Bales, among others, has opined on his WorkplaceProfBlog that the Massachusetts law is pre-empted.  Others have taken the opposite view, in part due to the options afforded employers (“pay or play”).

This week, a federal judge struck down a Maryland law that required any employer with more than 10,000 employees in Maryland to contribute at least 8% of payroll to health insurance benefits (known as the Wal-Mart law because, you guessed it, the law applied to only one employer), holding that it was pre-empted by ERISA.  Feel free to peruse the decision and order, as well as commentary from bloggers in Maryland (Below the Beltway) and Massachusetts (A Healthy Blog).

This decision holds special interest for Massachusetts, since the universal health care law here has a similar "pay-or-play" provision.  The Massachusetts law, however, requires payment of $295 per employee, not 8% of payroll per employee.  The judge in the Maryland decision distinguished the Massachusetts law in a footnote, saying:

Of course, I am expressing no opinion on whether legislative approaches taken by other States to the problems of health care delivery and its attendant costs would be preempted by ERISA. For example, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts has recently enacted legislation that addresses health care issues comprehensively and in a manner that arguably has only incidental effects upon ERISA plans. In light of what is generally perceived as a national health care crisis, it would seem that to the extent ERISA allows, it is strongly in the public interest to permit states to perform their traditional role of serving as laboratories for experiment in controlling the costs and increasing the quality of health care for all citizens.

The key distinction for this judge between the Massachusetts and Maryland plans seems to be that the Massachusetts plan is more comprehensive. A more cynical view would be that the the “penalty” for noncompliance is significantly greater in Maryland, and that is what contributed to the decision going the way it did. It remains to be seen whether the state will appeal — and whether this decision emboldens any potential plaintiffs in Massachusetts.

   

Filed Under: Massachusetts, Universal Health Care

you might also like:

  1. Federal appeals court upholds Wal-Mart win over Maryland "fair share" employee health benefits law

  2. ERISA pre-emption ruling bites San Fran health care coverage mandate

  3. Massachusetts universal health care costs — higher than expected or no?

« Whither the retail-based clinic?
Medicare rates to increase for nursing facilities »

Comments

  1. Chris says

    June 8, 2007 at 11:32 am

    BLAH! YUCK!
    I know that was going to happen:
    1. More burden on the small businesses.
    2. Exceptions for the big businesses.

Trackbacks

  1. Trusted.MD Network says:
    September 8, 2008 at 10:26 pm

    Massachusetts universal health insurance law: Changes in regs could prompt ERISA pre-emption challenge

    Massachusetts has famously gotten many of the state’s uninsured covered thanks to the state mandate. The “pay or play” approach taken has long seemed ripe for an ERISA pre-emption challenge (cf. the Wal-Mart case in Maryland). The program now seems…

Follow me on Twitter

David Harlow πŸ’‰πŸ˜· Follow 43,216 17,538

Mastodon @healthblawg@c.im #HealthCare #MedDevice #Compliance #Privacy @MyOmnipod #HIPAA #digitalhealth #HarlowOnHC #pinksocks Tweets are tweets No more no less

healthblawg
healthblawg avatar; David Harlow πŸ’‰πŸ˜· @healthblawg ·
33m 1639727201053491204

The Harlow #Healthcare #Innovation Daily https://paper.li/healthblawg/1489156253?share_id=4a12ea20-cb4c-11ed-a6d0-fa163e65ae25 #digitalhealth #hcldr #HarlowOnHC Thanks to @techguy @db_digest #digitalhealth #healthtech

Reply on Twitter 1639727201053491204 Retweet on Twitter 1639727201053491204 0 Like on Twitter 1639727201053491204 0 Twitter 1639727201053491204
healthblawg avatar; David Harlow πŸ’‰πŸ˜· @healthblawg ·
6h 1639640904406544391

ICYMI> David Sand, CMO of ZeOmega, an #AI-infused engine for β€œpayviders” β€” Harlow on Healthcare https://healthblawg.com/2022/10/david-sand-zeomega.html?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=ReviveOldPost #digitalhealth #hcldr #hitsm

Image for the Tweet beginning: ICYMI>  David Sand, CMO Twitter feed image.
Reply on Twitter 1639640904406544391 Retweet on Twitter 1639640904406544391 1 Like on Twitter 1639640904406544391 0 Twitter 1639640904406544391
healthblawg avatar; David Harlow πŸ’‰πŸ˜· @healthblawg ·
7h 1639630885497769985

The latest Harlow On Health Care Daily #HarlowOnHC #digitalhealth #healthcare #innovation #privacy #hcldr Thx: @rwneilljr @chidambara09 @SarahClarkBDM #digitalhealth #ai

Image for twitter card

AI's growing impact on echocardiography

cardiovascularbusiness.com Cardiology has the second largest number of FDA-cleared AI algorithms, and many of them are ...

paper.li

Reply on Twitter 1639630885497769985 Retweet on Twitter 1639630885497769985 0 Like on Twitter 1639630885497769985 0 Twitter 1639630885497769985
Load More
Follow me on Mastodon

HIPAAtools

Hipaatools

The HIPAA Compliance Toolkit

The Walking Gallery

The Walking Gallery

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Categories
  • Archives
  • Podcast Interviews
  • HIPAAtools
  • HIPAA Compliance
  • Health Care Social Media
  • Speaking
  • In the Press
  • Blogroll

David Harlow

David Harlow

HealthcareNOW Radio

Connect with David

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Email
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Book Me: Speaking
  • About
  • The Harlow Group LLC
Copyright © 2006–2023
HealthBlawg is a publication of The Harlow Group LLC. See Copyright notice and disclaimer.
Fair use with attribution and a link is encouraged. Click for more on David Harlow.
[footer_backtotop text="Back to top" href="#"]