HealthBlawg

David Harlow's Health Care Law Blog

    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • RSS
    • Email
  • About
  • Archives
  • Podcast
  • Press
  • Awards/Reviews
  • HIPAA
  • HCSM

ERISA pre-emption ruling bites San Fran health care coverage mandate

January 1, 2008

What better way to return from a week of vacation than with a little ERISA pre-emption jurisprudence.  To repeat my precis on the subject from just about this time last year: In a nutshell (and with apologies to ERISA lawyers), Federal ERISA law pre-empts state law that relates to insurance in the context of employee benefits.

It’s always interesting to see which health care coverage mandates founder on the rocks of ERISA pre-emption, which get a pass, and which don’t even have to be defended because nobody bothers to challenge them.  As usual, the bottom line is more about realpolitik than The True Meaning of ERISA (or whatever other law may be at issue); folks whose noses aren’t out of joint don’t sue — the lesson being: do your homework. 

For better or worse, witness the Massachusetts experience (no ERISA pre-emption challenge due in large part to the fact that employers and the SEIU were brought into the big tent early on) vs. Maryland and — this week’s poster child — San Francisco (both challenged and held pre-empted). 

For further reading on the recent San Fran ordinance being struck down, see the WSJ Health Blog and Stephen Rosenberg’s Boston ERISA and Insurance Litigation Blog.  (Rosenberg bemoans the choice of Maryland as test case; again, it seems to me that such challenges are brought only if the plaintiffs aren’t seated at the table.)  See my earlier post on the Maryland Wal-Mart ERISA decision here.

Update 1/10/08:  The federal appeals court ruled the San Francisco pay or play plan may be implemented pending appeal.  Score one for the city.  Employers are less than thrilled.

— David Harlow

Filed Under: Health care policy, Health Law, Massachusetts, Universal Health Care

you might also like:

  1. Massachusetts universal health insurance law: Changes in regs could prompt ERISA pre-emption challenge

  2. All Payor Claims Databases: ERISA Pre-emption and the Tragedy of the Commons

  3. Health insurance mandates: Geez, good thing Obama isn't pushing them, 'cause he'd get tied up in litigation for forever

« Anti-markup rule delay for some . . . Happy New Year from CMS
Maybe Dr. Drug Rep wasn't doing such a disservice to humanity »

Comments

  1. Paul Gillan says

    January 2, 2008 at 8:56 am

    . . . “witness the Massachusetts experience (no ERISA pre-emption challenge due in large part to the fact that employers and the SEIU were brought into the big tent early on)” . . .

    David, could you expand on which parts of the Mass. plan you would have expected to be challenged under ERISA? I was not aware that it included any employer-related mandates liked the Md. and Cal. efforts, but Mass. admittedly isn’t my bailiwick so I might’ve missed it.

  2. David Harlow says

    January 2, 2008 at 10:10 am

    Paul — I’m thinking of the pay or play employer mandate for firms with more than 10 FTEs. See http://www.mahealthconnector.org.

  3. Paul Gillan says

    January 2, 2008 at 10:20 am

    Very interesting. Thanks for the link!

  4. Wade Souza says

    January 2, 2008 at 2:35 pm

    The key is for states to approach this issue via their national legislators. Hawaii got an exclusion despite legal challenges. If enough states push the issue they should be able to do so also. The two national parties appear open to the states pushing this issue as a means to “test the waters” for national action.

  5. David Harlow says

    January 2, 2008 at 2:48 pm

    Wade — Excellent point. As the national health care debate gets teed up for the next Congress (or the one after that, or the one after that . . .), the states should continue to act as laboratories for experimentation in this arena. It would be nice if they could do so without having to look over their shoulders at the spectre of ERISA pre-emption.

Trackbacks

  1. HealthBlawg says:
    March 31, 2009 at 8:50 pm

    Health insurance mandates: Geez, good thing Obama isn’t pushing them, ’cause he’d get tied up in litigation for forever

    San Francisco’s municipal health insurance mandate is in the news again this week. The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the mandate in September (after sturm und drang and litigation over the San Francisco health insurance mandate going back almost…

Follow me on Twitter

David Harlow πŸ’‰πŸ˜· Follow 43,216 17,538

Mastodon @healthblawg@c.im #HealthCare #MedDevice #Compliance #Privacy @MyOmnipod #HIPAA #digitalhealth #HarlowOnHC #pinksocks Tweets are tweets No more no less

healthblawg
healthblawg avatar; David Harlow πŸ’‰πŸ˜· @healthblawg ·
6h 1639640904406544391

ICYMI> David Sand, CMO of ZeOmega, an #AI-infused engine for β€œpayviders” β€” Harlow on Healthcare https://healthblawg.com/2022/10/david-sand-zeomega.html?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=ReviveOldPost #digitalhealth #hcldr #hitsm

Image for the Tweet beginning: ICYMI>  David Sand, CMO Twitter feed image.
Reply on Twitter 1639640904406544391 Retweet on Twitter 1639640904406544391 1 Like on Twitter 1639640904406544391 0 Twitter 1639640904406544391
healthblawg avatar; David Harlow πŸ’‰πŸ˜· @healthblawg ·
6h 1639630885497769985

The latest Harlow On Health Care Daily #HarlowOnHC #digitalhealth #healthcare #innovation #privacy #hcldr Thx: @rwneilljr @chidambara09 @SarahClarkBDM #digitalhealth #ai

Image for twitter card

AI's growing impact on echocardiography

cardiovascularbusiness.com Cardiology has the second largest number of FDA-cleared AI algorithms, and many of them are ...

paper.li

Reply on Twitter 1639630885497769985 Retweet on Twitter 1639630885497769985 0 Like on Twitter 1639630885497769985 0 Twitter 1639630885497769985
healthblawg avatar; David Harlow πŸ’‰πŸ˜· @healthblawg ·
13h 1639535190774276096

ICYMI> Stephen Sweriduk, CMO of Shields Health Care on the evolution of diagnostic imaging β€” Harlow on Healthcare https://healthblawg.com/2022/01/sweriduk-shields-healthcare.html?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=ReviveOldPost #digitalhealth #hcldr #hitsm

Image for the Tweet beginning: ICYMI>  Stephen Sweriduk, CMO Twitter feed image.
Reply on Twitter 1639535190774276096 Retweet on Twitter 1639535190774276096 1 Like on Twitter 1639535190774276096 0 Twitter 1639535190774276096
Load More
Follow me on Mastodon

HIPAAtools

Hipaatools

The HIPAA Compliance Toolkit

The Walking Gallery

The Walking Gallery

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Categories
  • Archives
  • Podcast Interviews
  • HIPAAtools
  • HIPAA Compliance
  • Health Care Social Media
  • Speaking
  • In the Press
  • Blogroll

David Harlow

David Harlow

HealthcareNOW Radio

Connect with David

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Email
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Book Me: Speaking
  • About
  • The Harlow Group LLC
Copyright © 2006–2023
HealthBlawg is a publication of The Harlow Group LLC. See Copyright notice and disclaimer.
Fair use with attribution and a link is encouraged. Click for more on David Harlow.
[footer_backtotop text="Back to top" href="#"]